The Seasonality of Housing Demand and the Impact of Mortgage Rates on Home Sales Contracts

Housing demand has always been a highly seasonal phenomenon, influenced by a variety of factors, including weather patterns, school schedules, and financial markets. Traditionally, the spring and summer months see a surge in home-buying activity, with families trying to settle into new homes before the school year starts. Conversely, the fall and winter months usually experience a slowdown in housing demand as colder weather and holiday seasons keep many potential buyers on the sidelines.

However, recent data indicates a notable shift in the market. Despite the expected seasonal fluctuations, pending home sales contracts have firmed up lately, driven primarily by lower mortgage rates. In this context, a 6.4% increase in single-family homes going into contract compared to last year highlights a growing resilience in the housing market. This trend is particularly significant given the current affordability challenges in the broader real estate sector.

Seasonality in Housing Demand

Seasonality in housing demand reflects a predictable pattern where home-buying activity rises in certain months and declines in others. Historically, the market heats up from March to August, driven by the desire for families to move into new homes before the school year begins. During these months, weather is typically more favorable for house-hunting, open houses, and home inspections, making the process more appealing. The winter months, particularly around December, January, and February, tend to be the slowest, as colder climates and the holiday season divert attention away from real estate transactions. This predictable cycle creates what is often referred to as a “spring selling season” and a “winter lull.”

Despite this, housing demand isn't entirely dependent on the time of year. Economic conditions, notably mortgage rates, play a critical role in either amplifying or dampening seasonal trends. In recent months, lower mortgage rates have helped stabilize demand, counteracting the usual seasonal slowdown.

Mortgage Rates and Housing Demand

Mortgage rates are arguably the single most important factor in the housing market’s overall health. When mortgage rates are low, homes become more affordable to a broader range of buyers, fueling demand and driving up home prices. Conversely, when mortgage rates rise, affordability declines, leading to fewer home sales and, often, price adjustments.

Recently, we’ve seen mortgage rates hovering near levels that have allowed a stabilization of the housing market. However, for true sustained demand growth and a significant boost in home sales, mortgage rates would likely need to drop below 6% and remain there for an extended period. At present, while mortgage rates are not below this threshold, they are low enough to have helped stabilize the market and even increase pending sales contracts compared to last year.

This stabilization is particularly notable given that overall sales levels remain at record lows. The market's ability to flip from declining or stagnant activity to a 6.4% year-over-year increase in single-family homes in contract is a promising sign that lower mortgage rates, even above 6%, can have a meaningful impact on housing demand. However, the current increase in pending contracts should be understood within the broader context of the housing market’s affordability challenges, which remain a significant hurdle for many would-be buyers.

Affordability Challenges in the Housing Market

The affordability of homes has been a critical issue in the housing market, particularly in recent years as home prices have surged. These rising prices, coupled with elevated mortgage rates, have made it increasingly difficult for many buyers—especially first-time homebuyers—to enter the market.

Affordability is calculated based on three key factors: home prices, mortgage rates, and income levels. While incomes have grown somewhat in recent years, they have not kept pace with the rapid rise in home prices, resulting in a situation where many households are priced out of the market. Even with mortgage rates stabilizing, affordability remains a significant barrier to entry, particularly in high-cost housing markets.

In this context, the recent increase in pending home sales contracts is an encouraging sign. It suggests that while affordability remains a challenge, lower mortgage rates have been enough to entice a certain segment of buyers back into the market. These buyers may be taking advantage of price adjustments in certain areas or benefitting from more favorable financing terms to make home purchases more achievable.

Mortgage Rates: The Key to Sustained Demand Growth

While the recent firming up of housing demand is a positive development, true sustained demand growth will likely require mortgage rates to fall below 6% and remain there for an extended period. Historically, mortgage rates below this level have been associated with strong housing demand and robust sales activity. When mortgage rates dip below 6%, the monthly payments on a home loan become more manageable for a larger share of buyers, broadening the pool of potential homeowners.

Currently, while mortgage rates are not yet below 6%, they are low enough to have provided some relief to buyers and stabilized demand. The fact that pending sales contracts have increased 6.4% compared to last year is a testament to the market’s resilience in the face of affordability challenges. However, for this demand to be sustained over the long term, mortgage rates will need to continue trending lower, ideally below the 6% threshold.

Moreover, it’s not enough for mortgage rates to dip below 6% briefly; they need to stay there for an extended period to foster sustained demand growth. Temporary fluctuations in mortgage rates may provide short-term relief, but they do not offer the long-term stability that buyers and the broader housing market need for sustained growth.

The Role of Policy and Economic Factors

To understand where mortgage rates might head in the future, it's important to consider broader economic factors and policy decisions. Mortgage rates are influenced by a range of factors, including the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy, inflation rates, and the overall health of the economy. In recent months, the Federal Reserve’s decision to raise interest rates in response to inflationary pressures has contributed to higher mortgage rates. However, as inflation has begun to ease, there is hope that the Federal Reserve may pause or even reverse some of these rate hikes, potentially leading to lower mortgage rates in the future.

Additionally, housing policies aimed at increasing supply could help alleviate some of the affordability challenges that have plagued the market in recent years. Increasing the supply of affordable housing, either through new construction or incentives for developers, could help bring down home prices and make the market more accessible to a broader range of buyers.

The recent firming up of housing demand, as evidenced by a 6.4% increase in single-family homes going into contract, is a positive development for the market. While mortgage rates have not yet fallen below 6%, they are low enough to have stabilized demand and counteracted the typical seasonal slowdown in housing activity. However, for true sustained demand growth to occur, mortgage rates will likely need to fall below 6% and remain there for an extended period.

Affordability challenges remain a significant hurdle for many buyers, but the recent increase in pending contracts suggests that lower mortgage rates are providing some relief. Going forward, policy decisions and broader economic trends will play a critical role in determining whether mortgage rates can continue to fall and whether housing demand can continue to grow. For now, the market is showing signs of resilience, but sustained growth will require further improvements in both mortgage rates and housing affordability.

Shopping for a mortgage? Let me help you to find your best rate. Make an appointment by clicking here.

Warm regards,

Sharon, Your Safe Money Lady™

Sharon Ben-David

Phone: (954) 261-5200
Licensed Mortgage Broker, Certified Professional Retirement Planning Adviser, and Financial Advocate

Protecting Your Nest Egg, Inc.

NMLS #2308601