Retirement is a concept that has long been romanticized as a time for rest, relaxation, and enjoying the fruits of decades of labor. However, for today’s middle-class workers, the reality of retirement is shifting significantly. Many are now facing the prospect of working into old age, not necessarily by choice, but often due to financial necessity or a desire to remain active. With Social Security’s financial future uncertain, and policy discussions, like raising the retirement age, taking center stage, the landscape of retirement is undergoing profound changes.

Working Beyond Traditional Retirement Age: A Growing Trend

Gone are the days when turning 65 meant stepping away from work and transitioning into the golden years of retirement. For the middle class, a growing trend is emerging: continuing to work well beyond traditional retirement age. According to a recent report from Transamerica Center for Retirement Studies, nearly half of middle-class workers anticipate working past the age of 65, with some expecting to never fully retire.

There are multiple reasons for this shift. First and foremost, financial stability plays a significant role. Many individuals nearing retirement simply have not saved enough to maintain their lifestyle without income from employment. A study by the Economic Policy Institute found that the median retirement savings for those aged 56-61 was just $21,000, far below the amount needed for a secure retirement.

On top of inadequate savings, rising healthcare costs, housing expenses, and unexpected financial burdens often force older workers to continue earning a paycheck. While Social Security provides a safety net, for many, it is not enough to cover all expenses. The average monthly benefit is approximately $1,790 in 2024, according to the Social Security Administration (SSA). This amount often falls short when it comes to covering basic needs, particularly for those living in areas with high living costs.

Beyond financial reasons, there are other factors driving older adults to remain in the workforce. The desire to stay mentally and physically active plays a crucial role in the decision to work longer. Many workers report that they enjoy the social interaction and sense of purpose that comes with employment. In fact, some studies suggest that continuing to work can even contribute to better mental health outcomes in older adults, keeping them engaged and sharp.

Financial Necessity or Choice: A Complex Decision

For middle-class Americans, deciding whether to retire or continue working is often not a straightforward choice. While some may enjoy working longer and remaining productive, others feel compelled to do so out of necessity.

A major factor in this decision is the uncertainty surrounding Social Security’s future. The Social Security Board of Trustees has projected that the program’s combined trust funds (for old age and disability) could be depleted by 2034, meaning that beneficiaries might face a reduction in their monthly payments unless Congress takes action to shore up the program’s finances.

This impending crisis has sparked debate about the best course of action to ensure the sustainability of Social Security. One proposal that has gained attention is raising the full retirement age (FRA), which would mean workers need to wait longer to receive full Social Security benefits.

Raising the Retirement Age to 69: The Impact on Social Security

In August 2024, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) released a report analyzing the potential effects of raising the full retirement age to 69. Currently, the full retirement age is 67 for individuals born after 1960. Under this proposal, starting with Americans born in 1965, the FRA would gradually increase to 69 for those born in 1972 and later. This shift would have a significant impact on retirees and the Social Security program alike.

First, it’s important to understand how Social Security benefits work. Workers can begin claiming reduced benefits as early as age 62, but their monthly benefits increase the longer they delay claiming, up until age 70. The proposed change would still allow workers to claim reduced benefits at age 62, but the age at which they would receive their full benefits would increase to 69. This means that if workers continue to claim benefits at 62, their monthly payments would be even smaller than under the current system, leading to less financial security in old age.

While raising the retirement age would reduce the overall benefits that retirees receive over their lifetime, the CBO’s report found that it would improve Social Security’s financial outlook. By delaying when workers are eligible for full benefits, the program would save money in the long run, as fewer benefits would be paid out overall. However, the CBO also noted that raising the retirement age would not extend the program’s solvency beyond 2034, meaning that further reforms would still be necessary to prevent benefit cuts or tax increases in the future.

Consequences for Middle-Class Workers

For middle-class workers, raising the retirement age would present significant challenges. As it stands, many workers rely on Social Security as a key source of income in retirement. According to the Social Security Administration, nearly half of elderly beneficiaries receive 50% or more of their income from Social Security, and for one-quarter of beneficiaries, it represents 90% or more of their income.

A higher retirement age would disproportionately affect middle- and lower-income workers, who are less likely to have substantial retirement savings or pensions. Unlike higher earners, who often have more flexible retirement options, many middle-class workers will be forced to continue working longer to avoid a drastic reduction in their monthly Social Security benefits.

Furthermore, working into old age is not always feasible for everyone. While some workers are able to remain employed in less physically demanding roles, others may face challenges due to health issues, age discrimination, or caregiving responsibilities. According to a 2022 survey by AARP, nearly 60% of workers aged 50 and older reported experiencing age discrimination in the workplace. This can make it difficult for older workers to secure or retain employment, especially in industries that favor younger workers or require physical labor.

Delayed Retirement: Health and Well-Being Impacts

Working longer can have both positive and negative effects on an individual’s health and well-being. On one hand, continuing to work can provide mental stimulation, social interaction, and a sense of purpose. Research shows that older workers who remain engaged in meaningful work often report higher levels of satisfaction and better mental health than those who retire early and disengage from social activities.

On the other hand, for those who feel forced to work due to financial necessity, the experience can be stressful and take a toll on their physical and mental health. A study from the Journal of Gerontology found that workers who remain in physically demanding jobs into their late 60s or 70s are more likely to experience work-related injuries, chronic pain, and burnout. For many middle-class workers, the decision to delay retirement is not about choosing a healthier, more active lifestyle, but rather about meeting basic financial needs, which can exacerbate stress and lead to poor health outcomes.

Planning for a Future of Extended Working Years

As the concept of retirement evolves, middle-class workers are faced with the reality that they may need to remain employed longer than previous generations. For those who are financially prepared, continuing to work can be a fulfilling way to stay engaged and active. However, for many, the decision is driven by necessity rather than choice, highlighting the challenges of an uncertain retirement landscape.

To mitigate the impact of working longer, it’s essential for middle-class workers to plan early and save as much as possible. While saving for retirement may seem daunting, especially with the rising cost of living, taking advantage of employer-sponsored retirement plans, IRAs, and other savings vehicles can make a significant difference over time.

In addition, workers may benefit from pursuing careers or training in fields that are less physically demanding and more accommodating to older employees. Healthcare, education, and consulting are just a few industries that offer opportunities for older workers to remain active and employed without the physical demands of manual labor.

A Changing Future for Retirement

The notion of retirement is shifting, especially for the middle class. With rising costs, uncertain Social Security benefits, and the reality of working longer, retirement as we once knew it is becoming an elusive goal for many.

Whether driven by necessity or personal preference, the trend of working into old age is likely to continue as economic pressures, longevity, and policy changes shape the future of retirement in America. It’s crucial for workers, employers, and policymakers alike to recognize these challenges and adapt to ensure that the evolving retirement landscape is one where individuals can not only survive but thrive.

Warm regards,

Sharon, Your Safe Money Lady™

Sharon Ben-David

Phone: (954) 261-5200
Licensed Mortgage Broker, Certified Professional Retirement Planning Adviser, and Financial Advocate

Protecting Your Nest Egg, Inc.

NMLS #2308601